Guide

Mama’s Fish House Reservations: 18 Months Out, Phone or SevenRooms

George Yates · Founder, SeatSwiper · Updated November 17, 2026

How do you get a reservation at Mama’s Fish House on Maui?Call (808) 579-8488, where reservationists book lunch and dinner up to 18 months ahead from 9am to 9pm Hawaii time, or use the SevenRooms link on mamasfishhouse.com; OpenTable no longer takes its bookings. As of November 2026 there is no waitlist for future dates, parties are capped at eight, and late cancellations cost $50 per person, so most returned tables appear 24 to 48 hours before the date.
Book Mama’s Fish House on Maui the second a table opens.

SeatSwiper watches Mama’s Fish House on Maui on Resy, SevenRooms or OpenTable, then books it in your name the moment a table opens or someone cancels. First booking free.

Watch Mama’s Fish House on Maui for me

Mama’s Fish House sits on Kūʻau Bay at 799 Poho Place in Paia, about a mile and a half past Paia town on the road to Hana. Floyd and Doris Christenson opened it in 1973, their daughter Karen Christenson runs it now, and Executive Chef Perry Bateman, who became its first executive chef in 2000, still cooks fish brought in by named local fishermen. SFGATE called it one of Hawaii’s hardest places to get a reservation, and the reason is simple arithmetic: a restaurant that its own site says is “booked months in advance,” with no waitlist, a party cap of eight and a 24-hour cancellation fee. This guide covers how it books as of November 2026, from the restaurant’s own pages and its booking system.

Is Mama’s Fish House on OpenTable?

Not any more. The reservations section of mamasfishhouse.com says it plainly: “Reservations can no longer be booked on OpenTable’s app or website. They can be booked over the phone or via the link below.” The link opens a SevenRooms booking page, and the contact page adds that “booking reminders will be sent from our new system 48 hours before your reservation date.” That makes older advice wrong. In February 2023 Karen Christenson told SFGATE “Book your flight, book your hotel, then book your Mama’s,” and suggested OpenTable alerts for a full date. The first half still holds; the second can’t work now. So there are two ways in: the SevenRooms page on the restaurant’s site, and the phone at (808) 579-8488. If you have never used SevenRooms, how SevenRooms works explains the booking page and why each restaurant runs its own.

Book Mama’s Fish House on Maui the second a table opens.

SeatSwiper books it in your name the moment a table opens or someone cancels. First booking free.

Watch Mama’s Fish House on Maui for me

How far ahead can you book Mama’s Fish House?

Up to 18 months, by phone. The site’s wording is “Our Reservationists can book up to 18 months in advance for both Lunch & Dinner,” and the reservationists answer from 9am to 9pm Hawaii time every day. Hawaii does not change its clocks, so the mainland offset moves under you: until Sunday, March 14, 2027, that line is open from 11am to 11pm Pacific and from 2pm to 2am Eastern, and after the mainland springs forward it runs noon to midnight Pacific and 3pm to 3am Eastern.

Online is shorter. The public settings of Mama’s SevenRooms page, as I read them on November 16, 2026, cap searches at 365 days ahead and parties at one to eight guests. On that reading, any date after November 16, 2027 can only be reached by phone today, which covers Christmas and New Year’s Eve 2027 and the first months of 2028, up to the 18-month limit. The restaurant does not publish a release hour, and I could not confirm one, so I can’t tell you which morning a new date appears online; the phone is simply the longer reach. It also means the advice in the 2023 SFGATE piece has aged: it described reservations “taken up to a year out” and a restaurant “booked solid four to six months in advance.” The book is longer now, so the planning starts earlier: for a holiday week, call the day your travel dates are fixed.

When Mama’s is full

There is no waitlist to join. The contact page says “We do not offer a waitlist for future dates,” and then gives the single most useful line on the site: “If the date and time you are looking for is not available, we suggest checking back 24-48 hours before the desired reservation date. This is when most cancellations occur.” The policy explains why. Reminders go out 48 hours before each booking, and no-shows, cancellations and party-size changes made less than 24 hours ahead are charged $50 per person to the card on file. A table for four that is cancelled late costs its holder $200, so plans that changed get released in the day between the reminder and the fee line. That is the window to watch, two days and one day before your date, rather than the afternoon of. For openings, the site’s answer is the same phone number, 9am to 9pm HST. For how a fee line like this shapes when tables return elsewhere, see restaurant cancellation policies.

The other door is the bar. “Reservations are required, with the exception of bar seating which is seated on a first come first serve basis and is very limited,” and elsewhere the site repeats that a reservation is required for entry. A walk-in means the bar and nothing else, and with no bar seat count published, that is a gamble rather than a plan.

Lunch or dinner

Both book the same way and run all day. Lunch seats from 11am, last seating 3:30pm, and dinner from 4pm, last seating 8:45pm. The site lists a single Lunch & Dinner menu rather than two, and the reservationists book both up to 18 months out. If dinner is gone on your date, ask for a lunch time before giving up on the day; it is the same room on the bay, with the drive in daylight.

The rules that come with the table

A few policies decide whether your booking works at all. Eight is the ceiling: “we do not do group bookings. Single table reservations with a maximum of 8 guests only,” and the online page will not search above eight either, so a party of ten is two separate dinners or another restaurant. A credit card is required to hold every reservation. Special requests need 72 hours’ notice by email to info@mamasfishhouse.com. The dress code asks for “Smart Casual/Resort Casual to Dress-to-Impress attire,” footwear required, no tank tops for men, and hats off once seated in the main room or at the bar from 5pm. Children are welcome “but ask that they stay quiet and seated,” and parking is valet only.

One line matters more than it looks: “Reservations sold on third party websites will not be honored, and future reservations will be subject to cancellation.” A table bought from a reseller can be refused at the door and can cost you your other bookings, so book in your own name through the restaurant’s link or its phone.

Getting there on time

Where you are staying changes what time to book. The location page says to allow a minimum of an hour from Wailea or Kihei, and the same from Kaanapali or Lahaina, “due to traffic,” while the airport in Kahului is 15 to 20 minutes away. GPS sends you to the service entrance, so look for the fishing boat at the parking lot entrance instead. If you are coming off the Road to Hana, a late lunch slot is easier to keep than a fixed dinner time.

What the fuss is about

The menu is built on fish from boats the restaurant names: Greg and Teresa Ewart bring in mahi-mahi, ono and ahi, and Donniven Polendey’s family “has been fishing for Mama’s for over 45 years.” The Polynesian dining room comes from the founders, who sailed from San Diego to the Marquesas in 1960 before settling on Maui.

If you can’t get in

Merriman’s at Kapalua opens 60 days ahead at midnight Hawaii time on OpenTable, and The Restaurant at Hotel Wailea books on SevenRooms like Mama’s. Both, and a dozen more, are in Maui restaurant reservations. If your trip includes Honolulu, the same planning applies to the counters in Oahu restaurant reservations, and for the general rule on lead times see how far in advance to book reservations.

Full disclosure: SeatSwiper is my product. Everything in this guide works without it. The last section explains where it helps and exactly what it costs.

Watching Mama’s SevenRooms calendar

Mama’s asks you to recheck a SevenRooms page through the two days before your date and to catch a returned table before anyone else does. SeatSwiper watches Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, and Mama’s online book is on SevenRooms, so a watch on your date covers that 24 to 48 hour window and books the table the moment one opens or someone cancels. It books on your own SevenRooms account, in your name, for your own lunch or dinner, and nothing is resold or transferred. It can’t get your account banned, because it books on your own account and checks every few minutes, never nonstop. The first booking is free. After that it is a flat $5, charged only when it actually books the table, with no subscription. A cancellation watch on a date that is already full costs $1 to start, charged when the watch begins even if no table ever opens; that $1 is not covered by the free first booking and is not refunded, and the same $5 applies if the watch wins you the table. The honest limits: it works only on those three platforms, it needs your SevenRooms details to book as you, and it can lose a race for a single table. It also cannot phone the reservationists for the dates beyond a year, and it cannot take a bar seat for you.

FAQ

How far in advance can you book Mama’s Fish House?

Up to 18 months ahead by phone. The restaurant’s site says its reservationists book lunch and dinner up to 18 months in advance at (808) 579-8488, from 9am to 9pm Hawaii time daily. Its online SevenRooms page searched only up to 365 days ahead when read in November 2026, so for a date more than a year away, call. No release hour is published.

Can you still book Mama’s Fish House on OpenTable?

No. Mama’s Fish House says reservations can no longer be booked on OpenTable’s app or website, only by phone or through the SevenRooms link on mamasfishhouse.com, and reminders now come from the new system 48 hours before your date. Advice to set an OpenTable alert for a full date, which the owner gave SFGATE in 2023, no longer applies.

Does Mama’s Fish House have a waitlist?

Not for future dates; the contact page says so directly. Instead it suggests checking back 24 to 48 hours before the date you want, when most cancellations happen. That timing follows its own policy: reminders go out 48 hours ahead, and cancelling inside 24 hours costs $50 per person. Bar seats are first come, first served and very limited.

What is the cancellation policy at Mama’s Fish House?

A credit card is required for every reservation, and no-shows, cancellations or changes in party size made less than 24 hours ahead are charged $50 per person to that card. Tables are capped at eight guests with no group bookings, special requests need 72 hours’ notice by email, and reservations bought on third-party websites are not honored.

Related guides