Sarasota Restaurant Reservations: Longboat Key to Siesta Key
George Yates · Founder, SeatSwiper · Updated November 17, 2026
Pick the Sarasota table you want and SeatSwiper watches it on Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, then books it in your name the moment one opens or someone cancels. First booking free.
Start a Sarasota watchSarasota is not a town where tables vanish in the first second of a release. It is a town where the good ones are gone because someone booked in October. Almost every room people ask about here books on OpenTable, with windows running from 30 days to a full year, and the few on Resy publish no window at all. The way to lose a February dinner on Longboat Key is not to be slow; it is to be late, or to call a restaurant on its closed night, or to book a party of six online where the house only takes five or more by phone. This guide goes island by island, then downtown, as of November 2026, and every rule in it comes from the restaurant’s own site or its OpenTable or Resy listing.
Book-ahead, not a race
On OpenTable, a rolling window adds one new date every night at midnight Eastern, and nothing about the hour gives anyone an edge. What matters is the length of the window. As of November 2026, OpenTable’s schedule shows the two St. Regis restaurants on Longboat Key at 30 days, Michael’s On East, Euphemia Haye, Ophelia’s on the Bay and Veronica at 90, Sage at 181 and Selva Grill at 365. A March weekend is already open at Selva and Sage, opens in December at the 90-day rooms, and will not open at the St. Regis until February. For a wider look at windows like these, see how far in advance to book reservations.
SeatSwiper watches the Sarasota table you want and books it in your name the moment one opens. First booking free.
Start a Sarasota watchLongboat Key
The island between Sarasota and Anna Maria has the town’s most formal dining, and its rules are written down.
- Maison Blanche (Longboat Key, Four Winds Beach Resort). Chef José Martinez cooks a set prix fixe with no à la carte, built from seven appetizers, seven mains and seven desserts, the “Table d’hôte” format, with wine and champagne only and no outside bottles. It books on Resy and needs a card: no-shows and changes inside 24 hours cost $50 per guest, and a table is held 15 minutes. It opens at 5pm and is closed on Mondays from November to April, on Mondays and Tuesdays from May to October, and on Christmas Day and New Year’s Day. Book Maison Blanche with SeatSwiper
- Euphemia Haye (Longboat Key, 5540 Gulf of Mexico Drive). Open since 1975 and chef-owned since 1980, with a garden dining room and the Haye Loft upstairs. It takes OpenTable bookings and phone calls after 1pm, but parties of five or more must book by phone, and the Loft and dessert room take no reservations at all. Anyone who ate downstairs is guaranteed a seat upstairs for dessert, so the Loft is also the walk-in plan. Book Euphemia Haye with SeatSwiper
- Harry’s Continental Kitchens (Longboat Key, 525 Saint Judes Drive). Serving the island since 1979, from breakfast through dinner, Tuesday to Sunday. It is on Resy, and so are its winter wine dinners, which sell as separate events on their own dates. Book Harry’s Continental Kitchens with SeatSwiper
- CW Prime (Longboat Key, The St. Regis). The resort’s steakhouse, cooking over a Josper charcoal grill. Thirty days on OpenTable’s schedule, the shortest window in this guide, so a holiday table here cannot be booked early even if you try. Book CW Prime with SeatSwiper
- Riva (Longboat Key, The St. Regis). The resort’s northern Italian room, on the same 30-day schedule as CW Prime. Book Riva with SeatSwiper
Anna Maria Island
- Beach Bistro (Holmes Beach, 6600 Gulf Drive). The name people search for on the island: a mahogany, “Old-Florida” room directly on the Gulf beach, open for dinner every night from 4pm to 10pm, serving a four-course tasting menu. It books on Resy, and you choose between the bar lounge, the main dining room and the beach patio. The site says patio seating is limited and depends on weather and availability, so have a dining room table as the backup when you ask for outside. It also takes bookings by phone at 941-778-1619. No booking window is published. Book Beach Bistro with SeatSwiper
Siesta Key
- Ophelia’s on the Bay (Siesta Key). A waterfront room on the bay side, dinner nightly from 5pm to 10pm. OpenTable at 90 days, or by phone at 941-349-2212, and the site asks you to call for holiday hours. Book Ophelia’s on the Bay with SeatSwiper
- Summer House (Siesta Key, 149 Avenida Messina). A steakhouse “with a seafood attitude,” and the only SevenRooms restaurant here. Parties of eight or more must call, and Sunday brunch runs 10am to 2pm. Book Summer House with SeatSwiper
Downtown and Southside Village
- Michael’s On East (Sarasota). The 1940s-style supper club that has been serving since 1987, with a Piano Lounge. OpenTable’s schedule shows 90 days at midnight, so Presidents’ Day weekend became bookable on November 15 to 17. Book Michael’s On East with SeatSwiper
- Sage (Downtown, First Street). A globe-trotting menu in a historic building in the theater district. The restaurant itself says to book because it serves “a high volume of guests.” OpenTable shows 181 days, so the whole season is open now. Book Sage with SeatSwiper
- Selva Grill (Downtown, 1345 Main Street). Latin cooking that The New York Times called “possibly the best food in Sarasota,” a line its website quotes. It runs to 1am on Fridays and Saturdays, a year-long book on OpenTable’s schedule, and a second Selva at University Town Center with its own listing: make sure the one you book is downtown. Book Selva Grill with SeatSwiper
- Veronica Fish & Oyster (Southside Village, 1830 South Osprey Avenue). A modern oyster bar with a supper-club nod, open to midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. OpenTable at 90 days for four or fewer; five or more call directly. Book Veronica Fish & Oyster with SeatSwiper
- Antoine’s (Sarasota, 1100 North Tuttle Avenue). A cozy French-continental room since 2013, with PEI mussels cooked ten ways and everything from bread to dessert made in house. Resy only, dinner 5pm to 9pm, Tuesday to Saturday. This is not the 1840 French Quarter institution; for that one, see Antoine’s in New Orleans. Book Antoine’s with SeatSwiper
The rules that cost people the night
Sarasota’s restaurants say plainly how they want to be booked, and the rules differ by a guest or a day. Five or more must call at Euphemia Haye and Veronica; at Summer House the line is eight. Maison Blanche is shut on Mondays all winter, Antoine’s on Sundays and Mondays, and Harry’s on Mondays. Maison Blanche’s $50-a-guest charge applies to a change inside 24 hours as well as a no-show, so changing your party size the morning of dinner is not free. Read the policy on the confirmation screen before you tap through; what the usual wording means is set out in restaurant cancellation policies.
Season dates to count from
Sarasota’s busy months run from the winter holidays through Easter, which is March 28 in 2027. On the 30-day books at the St. Regis, Christmas Eve opens on November 24, New Year’s Eve on December 1 and Presidents’ Saturday, February 13, on January 14. On the 90-day books, Presidents’ weekend is already open, a mid-March Saturday opens in mid-December, and Easter Saturday, March 27, opens on December 27. Sage already reaches mid-May and Selva next November. The Resy rooms, Maison Blanche, Beach Bistro, Harry’s and Antoine’s, publish no window, so check them the day your dates are fixed. If your trip continues south, the same approach works for Naples restaurant reservations, and the east coast is covered in Palm Beach restaurant reservations and Miami restaurant reservations.
When the date you want is already gone
In a book-ahead town, the useful tool is a cancellation watch, because some of the people who booked in October will change their plans. I built SeatSwiper to do that. You tell it the restaurant, the night and the party size; it keeps checking OpenTable, Resy or SevenRooms and takes the table as soon as one comes free, whether someone cancelled or the window reached your date. The booking is made on your own account and in your name, and nothing is resold. The first booking is free. After that it is a flat $5, charged only when it actually books the table, with no subscription. A cancellation watch on a date that is already full costs $1 to start, charged when the watch begins even if no table ever opens; that $1 is not covered by the free first booking and is not refunded, and the same $5 applies if the watch wins you the table. It can’t get your account banned, because it books on your own account and checks every few minutes, never nonstop. It cannot make a phone booking for a party of five at Euphemia Haye, it has to be connected to your account to book in your name, and on a popular night someone else can still get there first, so treat it as better odds, not a promise.
FAQ
How far ahead should you book dinner in Sarasota in season?
Earlier than the platform suggests. As of November 2026, OpenTable’s schedule shows Riva and CW Prime at The St. Regis Longboat Key at 30 days, Michael’s On East, Euphemia Haye, Ophelia’s on the Bay and Veronica at 90, Sage at 181 and Selva Grill at 365. Nothing here is a release-morning race; the tables go to whoever booked first.
How do you book Maison Blanche on Longboat Key?
On Resy or by phone at (941) 383-8088. The restaurant asks for a card and charges $50 per guest for a no-show or a change inside 24 hours, and holds a table 15 minutes. It serves only a set table d’hôte menu with wine and champagne, no cocktails. It is closed Mondays from November to April and on Christmas Day and New Year’s Day.
Is Beach Bistro on Anna Maria Island on Resy?
Yes. Beach Bistro at 6600 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach books on Resy, by phone at 941-778-1619 or by email, and serves a four-course tasting menu every night from 4pm to 10pm. You can ask for the bar lounge, the main dining room or the beach patio, but the restaurant says patio seating depends on weather and availability.
Which Sarasota restaurants require a phone call for larger groups?
Several, and the cutoffs differ. Euphemia Haye on Longboat Key and Veronica Fish & Oyster in Southside Village take parties of five or more by phone only, and Summer House on Siesta Key asks groups of eight or more to call. Euphemia Haye’s upstairs Haye Loft and dessert room take no reservations at all and are walk-in only.