Nantucket Restaurant Reservations: The Hardest Tables and Windows
George Yates · Founder, SeatSwiper · Updated November 17, 2026
Pick the Nantucket table you want and SeatSwiper watches it on Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, then books it in your name the moment one opens or someone cancels. First booking free.
Start a Nantucket watchMost of Nantucket’s hardest tables cannot be booked far ahead. Lola 41 and The Nautilus open a week out at 10am, Straight Wharf two weeks out, and a month-long window is the exception. The skill here is knowing the morning, not the month. It is also November: part of the list is closed until spring, and the rest is pointed at Christmas Stroll, December 4 to 6, 2026. As of November 16, 2026, from each restaurant’s site or Resy page, the Nantucket Island Chamber of Commerce and, where a venue is silent, OpenTable’s schedule.
A week out at 10am: Lola 41 and The Nautilus
The two names people search hardest run the same clock: seven days ahead at 10am Eastern, so a July Saturday opens the Saturday before (what time Resy releases reservations).
- Lola 41 (Resy, Nantucket). The global bistro and sushi bar named for the 41st parallel, its menu drawn from cities along that line. Its Resy page says every reservation is on Resy and opens 7 days ahead at 10:00am. Bar seats are walk-in with an on-site waitlist, tables are held 15 minutes, and you get two hours (two and a quarter for five or more). Book Lola 41 with SeatSwiper
- The Nautilus (OpenTable, Cambridge Street). The small-plates house that started here in 2014. Its site: tables open 1 week ahead on OpenTable from 10am, the bar is always walk-in, and the Captain’s Table books by voicemail from midnight one month ahead. It lists dinner nightly at 5:30 but is not on the Chamber’s Stroll list, so check OpenTable before planning December around it. Book The Nautilus with SeatSwiper
SeatSwiper watches the Nantucket table you want and books it in your name the moment one opens. First booking free.
Start a Nantucket watchTwo weeks out
Fourteen days is the island’s other common window.
- Straight Wharf Restaurant (Resy, Harbor Square). The harborside classic just closed what it calls its 51st anniversary season, signing off “See you in May.” Tables open two weeks out on Resy for up to eight; nine to twelve email, and those book 30 days ahead. Its Resy page lists a $90 two-course prix fixe, no à la carte, and the deck by request only. Dinner 5:30 to 10, Tuesday to Sunday. Book Straight Wharf Restaurant with SeatSwiper
- The Pearl (Resy, Federal Street). Asian-inspired plates and cocktails at 12 Federal Street, reopening from its fall break on November 18. Tables open 14 days ahead at 10am for up to seven, with space always held for walk-ins. For Stroll it broke its own rule: November and Stroll tables all opened November 1 at 10am, and the December 3 to 5 Stroll dinners are a two-course prix fixe. Book The Pearl with SeatSwiper
- The Gaslight (OpenTable, North Union Street). Late-night music and dinner, serving Thursday to Saturday from 5pm, OpenTable or walk-in. OpenTable’s schedule shows 14 days at 10am. Book The Gaslight with SeatSwiper
- Millie’s (Resy, Madaket). Closed for 2026; Madaket reopens May 13, 2027 and the walk-in Rotary counter on April 8. Only Madaket books, 14 days ahead at 11am, and only for 4 to 5:30pm and 7:45pm on. The hours between are walk-in, and it saves 90% of the room that way. Book Millie’s with SeatSwiper
A month or more: the rooms you can plan around
A holiday dinner gets fixed weeks ahead here (when OpenTable releases tables).
- Queequeg’s (Resy, Oak Street). The bistro behind the Atheneum, named for the Moby-Dick character. Dinner books 30 days ahead, in house or online, with a card and a $50-a-person fee inside 48 hours; lunch takes no bookings. Open year-round, and the Chamber lists dinner every night but Sunday. Book Queequeg’s with SeatSwiper
- Town (Resy, East Chestnut Street). Queequeg’s sister, sharing one menu with it this year, with the outdoor Tree Bar. Same 30-day book and $50 rule. Its winter break runs December 20 to February 10, so the holidays are Queequeg’s alone. Book Town with SeatSwiper
- The Proprietors (OpenTable, India Street). Opened in 2013 by Michael and Orla LaScola, formerly of American Seasons; dinner Thursday to Monday from 5pm. Its site says OpenTable takes one to eight up to 30 days ahead. OpenTable’s schedule shows 42, so plan on the restaurant’s 30. Book The Proprietors with SeatSwiper
- Oran Mor Bistro (OpenTable, South Beach Street). A small bistro open Friday to Monday from 5pm this fall, with a Thanksgiving menu from 1 to 7pm. OpenTable’s schedule shows 30 days ahead at 10am. Book Oran Mor Bistro with SeatSwiper
- or, The Whale (OpenTable, Main Street). Closed until November 25, per the Chamber. OpenTable’s schedule shows 42 days opening at noon, which put Christmas Eve on sale November 12 and New Year’s Eve November 19. Book or, The Whale with SeatSwiper
- The Club Car (OpenTable, 1 Main Street). A 19th-century train car with live piano Thursday to Sunday at 9pm; open seasonally, walk-ins welcome, and closed until Stroll per the Chamber. OpenTable’s schedule is the odd one: a whole month opens on the 28th, two months ahead, at 10am. December opened October 28, January opens November 28, and all of July 2027 opens May 28. Book The Club Car with SeatSwiper
Set menus, hotel rooms and one SevenRooms book
- The Company of the Cauldron (Resy, India Street). One prix fixe a night, posted on its site before you book, from Michelin-starred chef Joseph Keller, Thomas Keller’s brother. Summer seatings are 7pm nightly or 6 and 8:30 on Fridays and Saturdays. Closed until November 19, per the Chamber. Its site charges $100 a person inside 48 hours (its Resy page says $50) and asks you to call 508-228-4016 with requests. Book The Company of the Cauldron with SeatSwiper
- The Chanticleer (Resy, ’Sconset). The rose-covered cottage that opened as a small tea house at the turn of the century, now cooked by executive chef Andre Miller. Its Resy page: reopening Memorial Day weekend 2027 (Memorial Day is May 31). Book The Chanticleer with SeatSwiper
- Ventuno (Resy, Federal Street). Cured meats, crostini, house pasta and seafood at 21 Federal Street, dinner Wednesday to Saturday. Its site said Stroll bookings would go live October 17 at noon, on Resy only. Book Ventuno with SeatSwiper
- Sister Ship (SevenRooms, Centre Street). The restaurant at Faraway Nantucket, 29 Centre Street, open for Stroll with dinner Tuesday to Saturday. SevenRooms publishes no window; the booking page belongs to the restaurant (how SevenRooms works). Book Sister Ship with SeatSwiper
- Brant Point Grill (Resy, Easton Street). The White Elephant’s harbor-view room, with holiday buffets on Thanksgiving (November 26) and Stroll Sunday (December 6); closed Monday and Tuesday. Book Brant Point Grill with SeatSwiper
- American Seasons (Resy, Centre Street). Chef-owner Neil Ferguson’s room at 80 Centre Street is closed for the season and reopens in April 2027, per its site. Bar seats are walk-in only. Book American Seasons with SeatSwiper
Christmas Stroll, December 4 to 6
The Chamber’s 52nd Stroll runs Friday to Sunday, with the marketplace Saturday from 10am to 3pm. Several Stroll books opened weeks ago (Ventuno October 17, The Club Car’s December October 28, The Pearl November 1), and the 30-day rooms reached Saturday the 5th on November 5. Still to time: The Gaslight reaches the 5th on November 21, and Lola 41 and The Nautilus open it at 10am on Saturday, November 28. Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve are Thursdays: Queequeg’s puts them on sale November 24 and December 1, and if Lola 41 is serving, its book reaches them at 10am on December 17 and 24. Town is closed for both.
Booking next summer from March
With windows this short, there is nothing to book for July at Lola 41 in March; mark the mornings instead. For Saturday, July 3, 2027 (the Fourth is a Sunday): The Club Car’s whole July opens May 28 at 10am, or, The Whale May 22 at noon, Queequeg’s, Oran Mor and The Proprietors June 3, Straight Wharf, The Pearl and The Gaslight June 19, and Lola 41 and The Nautilus June 26 at 10am. Lola 41’s Memorial Day Saturday, May 29, opens May 22. The Daffodil Festival is April 22 to 25, 2027; a Queequeg’s table for Saturday the 24th opens March 25.
When the book is full
Nantucket keeps more seats off the apps than most resort towns: Lola 41, The Nautilus and American Seasons hold the bar for walk-ins, The Pearl keeps space, and Millie’s holds nine-tenths of Madaket, so arriving at opening often beats refreshing. Fees tell you when booked tables come back. Queequeg’s and Town charge $50 a person inside 48 hours and the Cauldron $100, so plans change before that line; check two or three days out (reading a cancellation policy). For the rest of the trip, see the hardest restaurants to book in Boston, Martha’s Vineyard restaurant reservations and Cape Cod restaurant reservations.
One watch for a week-out island
I built SeatSwiper for books like this one. It watches Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable and books the table the moment one opens, when a new date enters the window or someone cancels: Lola 41 and Straight Wharf on Resy, The Nautilus and The Club Car on OpenTable, Sister Ship on SevenRooms. It books on your own account on each platform, in your name, and nothing is resold or transferred. It can’t get your account banned, because it books on your own account and checks every few minutes, never nonstop. The first booking is free. After that it is a flat $5, charged only when it actually books the table, with no subscription. A cancellation watch on a date that is already full costs $1 to start, charged when the watch begins even if no table ever opens; that $1 is not covered by the free first booking and is not refunded, and the same $5 applies if the watch wins you the table. It works only on those three platforms, it needs each account connected so it can book as you, and at 10am on a July Saturday it can lose the race. It is never a guarantee.
FAQ
How far in advance can you book Lola 41 on Nantucket?
Seven days. Lola 41’s Resy page says every reservation is on Resy and opens 7 days in advance at 10:00am Eastern, so a Saturday table opens the Saturday before at 10am. Bar seats are walk-in only, with a waitlist managed on site, and tables are held for 15 minutes. As of November 2026 it was taking bookings on that schedule.
When do Nantucket restaurants take Christmas Stroll reservations?
Each on its own schedule, and several already have. Stroll runs December 4 to 6, 2026. The Pearl opened November and Stroll tables on November 1 at 10am, Ventuno opened Stroll on Resy on October 17 at noon, and OpenTable’s schedule put The Club Car’s whole December on sale October 28. Lola 41 and The Nautilus open Saturday, December 5 at 10am on November 28.
Which Nantucket restaurants are open in the winter?
As of November 2026, Queequeg’s is open year-round for dinner (closed Sundays), and Town until its December 20 to February 10 break. The Proprietors, Sister Ship, Ventuno, The Pearl and Brant Point Grill are on the Chamber’s Stroll list. Straight Wharf returns in May, American Seasons in April, The Chanticleer on Memorial Day weekend and Millie’s Madaket on May 13, 2027.
Can you book Straight Wharf for a big group?
Yes, by email. Up to eight book on Resy two weeks ahead, but for nine to twelve Straight Wharf asks you to email info@straightwharfrestaurant.com, and those larger tables can be reserved 30 days in advance, sixteen days earlier than a couple can book. Its Resy page lists a $90 two-course prix fixe and the harbor deck by request only.