Key West Restaurant Reservations: Windows From 60 Days to a Year
George Yates · Founder, SeatSwiper · Updated November 17, 2026
Pick the Key West table you want and SeatSwiper watches it on Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, then books it in your name the moment one opens or someone cancels. First booking free.
Start a Key West watchKey West makes the platform question easy: nearly every restaurant worth planning around books on OpenTable, and in this guide only Hot Tin Roof (Resy) and Four Flamingos (SevenRooms) are the exceptions. What changes from door to door is the window. As of November 2026 the shortest books here run 60 days and the longest a full year, and the hardest table in town, Little Pearl, also limits each night to three fixed seatings. So the useful question for a Key West dinner is not which app, it is how far out the date you want went on sale. This guide groups Old Town, Stock Island and the Upper Keys by that number, using each restaurant’s own website and OpenTable’s published schedule.
Little Pearl, and which Little Pearl
Two restaurants share the name. This one is Little Pearl Key West, at 632 Olivia Street on the corner of Elizabeth, in the residential part of Old Town. The other is Aaron Silverman’s Little Pearl on Capitol Hill, which books on Resy and has its own guide: Little Pearl reservations in DC.
- Little Pearl (Old Town, Olivia Street). A neighborhood wine bar and fish house serving one thing at dinner: a custom four-course menu of local seafood. It seats three times a night, at 5pm, 7pm and 9pm, and closes on Sundays, so a week has eighteen chances for a table and no flexible times in between. It books on OpenTable, where the schedule shows a 90-day window that opens at midnight Eastern, and its own site also says to call the restaurant to book, at 305-204-4762. If the 7pm seating is gone, take 5pm or 9pm rather than waiting for 7 to come back. Book Little Pearl with SeatSwiper
SeatSwiper watches the Key West table you want and books it in your name the moment one opens. First booking free.
Start a Key West watchSixty days: the shortest books in town
These are the rooms you cannot book early even if you want to, which is also why their holiday dates come up late.
- Hot Tin Roof (Old Town, Ocean Key Resort). The resort’s harbor-view room at the foot of Duval, Cuban and Caribbean influences under chef Scott Maurer, dinner daily 6pm to 9pm. It is the Resy exception here, and its Resy listing says online reservations open 60 days in advance. It is cashless, and it serves a prix fixe on both Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. Book Hot Tin Roof with SeatSwiper
- Fishwife (Key West, 223 Petronia Street). The downtown sister of The Docks on Stock Island, a raw bar open daily from 11:30am to 10pm. OpenTable at 60 days, and because it serves all day, lunch is a real option when dinner is booked. Book Fishwife with SeatSwiper
- Salt + Ash (Duck Key, Hawks Cay Resort). Jeremy Ford’s wood-fire restaurant at Hawks Cay, up the Overseas Highway on Duck Key. Also 60 days on OpenTable. The resort says reservations are strongly recommended for everyone and required for groups of eight or more, and that hours vary by season. Book Salt + Ash with SeatSwiper
Ninety days: most of Old Town
- Santiago’s Bodega (Bahama Village, 207 Petronia Street). Globally inspired tapas, wine and beer only. Its reservations page carries two OpenTable widgets, one for Key West and one for its Orlando location, so check which one you are in. The FAQ strongly recommends booking, welcomes walk-ins when there is room, and takes a reservation up to three hours ahead; anything closer is treated as a walk-in. Book Santiago’s Bodega with SeatSwiper
- A&B Lobster House (Old Town, 700 Front Street). Fine dining on Front Street since 1947, with Maine and Florida lobster and balcony tables. OpenTable at 90 days. Book A&B Lobster House with SeatSwiper
- Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar (Stock Island, The Perry Hotel). Marina-side comfort food on the working waterfront at 7001 Shrimp Road, dinner 5:30pm to 9:30pm daily, away from the Duval Street crowds. OpenTable at 90 days. Book Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar with SeatSwiper
Five months to a year
At the long end, the window is so wide that next spring is already on sale. Waiting for a date to open is pointless here; what decides a table is when you started looking.
- Café Marquesa (Old Town, 600 Fleming Street). The Marquesa Hotel’s dining room in the 1884 James Haskins House, one block off Duval. Chef Travis Lee, who cooked at Mujō in Atlanta and at The Fat Duck, serves dinner daily from 5pm to 9pm, à la carte or as a seven-course tasting at $165, and the tasting is served only from 5:30pm to 8pm. The hotel says anyone can book, on OpenTable or at 305-292-1244, and OpenTable’s schedule shows 151 days. Book Café Marquesa with SeatSwiper
- Seven Fish (Old Town, 921 Truman Avenue). The casual local-fish bistro, open 6pm to 10pm and closed on Tuesdays. Its OpenTable book runs 365 days, and its Christmas Eve dinner, a multi-course seafood menu with live music, runs from 5pm to 10pm. Book Seven Fish with SeatSwiper
- Nine One Five (Old Town, 915 Duval Street). Bistro and bar in an old Victorian house, open daily 5pm to 11pm. It recommends reservations by phone at 305-296-0669 or through OpenTable, which shows 365 days, and parties of more than 12 must call. Book Nine One Five with SeatSwiper
- Martin’s (Old Town, 917 Duval Street). Steak, lobster and German dishes like schnitzel and spätzle, dinner from 4pm every night. Also 365 days on OpenTable, and the restaurant says walk-in seating is often available in the lounge. Book Martin’s with SeatSwiper
- Pierre’s (Islamorada, Morada Bay). Fine dining upstairs in a colonial-style house on the beach at mile marker 81.6, facing the sunset. OpenTable’s schedule shows 365 days. It is a long drive from Key West, so it is a dinner for a stay in the Upper Keys. Book Pierre’s with SeatSwiper
The SevenRooms room on Front Street
- Four Flamingos (Old Town, Hyatt Centric). Richard Blais’s Key West kitchen, dinner daily 5pm to 9pm, with tables on the sand. It books through SevenRooms and publishes no window, and groups of 20 or more go through the hotel’s events team. How SevenRooms works explains why a blank SevenRooms calendar is harder to read than an OpenTable one. Book Four Flamingos with SeatSwiper
Holiday dates, counted out
Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve 2026 both fall on Thursdays. On the 90-day books, both were on sale by early October, so any Little Pearl seating still open for those nights is one nobody has taken or one somebody gave back. On the 60-day books, Christmas Eve opened on October 25 and New Year’s Eve on November 1. For the Presidents’ Day long weekend (Saturday, February 13, to Monday, February 15, 2027), the 60-day rooms open the Saturday on December 15 and the 90-day rooms reached it on November 15. Valentine’s Day is the Sunday of that weekend, and Little Pearl is closed on Sundays, so the Saturday is the night to aim for there. The mechanics of the nightly roll are covered in when OpenTable releases reservations; for windows a year long, read how far in advance to book reservations.
No table? Where the door still works
Martin’s lounge takes walk-ins, Santiago’s welcomes them when it has space, and Fishwife’s all-day hours make an early meal an easy fallback. For Little Pearl, the phone is worth a try, because its own site tells you to call the restaurant to book. Traveling on through Florida? The same counting works for Miami restaurant reservations and Naples restaurant reservations.
A watch on a sold-out Key West night
When the seating you wanted is gone, I would rather a tool keep checking than you. That is what SeatSwiper does. It works on OpenTable, where nearly all of Key West is, and on Resy and SevenRooms, and it grabs a matching table when someone cancels or when the window reaches your night, using your own account, in your name. Nothing is resold or transferred. The first booking is free. After that it is a flat $5, charged only when it actually books the table, with no subscription. A cancellation watch on a date that is already full costs $1 to start, charged when the watch begins even if no table ever opens; that $1 is not covered by the free first booking and is not refunded, and the same $5 applies if the watch wins you the table. It can’t get your account banned, because it books on your own account and checks every few minutes, never nonstop. It cannot take a seating that a restaurant fills by phone, it books only through an account you have connected, and for a Saturday 7pm it can still come second. There is no guarantee.
FAQ
How do you get a reservation at Little Pearl in Key West?
Little Pearl Key West, at 632 Olivia Street, books on OpenTable, where the schedule shows a 90-day window as of November 2026, and its site also says to call the restaurant on 305-204-4762. It serves a custom four-course menu at three seatings, 5pm, 7pm and 9pm, and is closed Sundays. It is not the Little Pearl on Capitol Hill in DC, which books on Resy.
How far ahead do Key West restaurants take reservations?
From 60 days to a year. As of November 2026, Hot Tin Roof’s Resy listing opens 60 days ahead and OpenTable’s schedule shows Fishwife and Salt + Ash at 60, Little Pearl, Santiago’s Bodega, A&B Lobster House and Matt’s Stock Island at 90, Café Marquesa at 151, and Seven Fish, Nine One Five and Martin’s at 365.
Can you book Café Marquesa if you are not staying at The Marquesa Hotel?
Yes. The hotel says Café Marquesa takes reservations from anyone, through OpenTable or by phone on 305-292-1244. Dinner runs daily from 5pm to 9pm, à la carte or as a seven-course tasting menu at $165, and the tasting is served only between 5:30pm and 8pm, so book an early slot if you want it.
Which Key West restaurants take walk-ins?
A few say so on their own sites. Martin’s on Duval Street says walk-in seating is often available in its lounge, and Santiago’s Bodega welcomes walk-ins when it has room, though it treats any booking made less than three hours ahead as a walk-in. Fishwife on Petronia Street serves from 11:30am to 10pm, so an early meal is an easy fallback.