Hamptons Restaurant Reservations: Winter Tables and Summer Windows
George Yates · Founder, SeatSwiper · Updated November 17, 2026
Pick the Hamptons table you want and SeatSwiper watches it on Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, then books it in your name the moment one opens or someone cancels. First booking free.
Start a Hamptons watchIn November the Hamptons book like two different towns. A short list of rooms keeps taking reservations all winter, some of them every night of the year. The summer scene, from Si Si on Three Mile Harbor to Alba Spiaggia at the Montauk Yacht Club, has closed for the 2026 season and will not show a table until next year. Nearly all of the East End books on Resy; Sag Harbor Tavern, Almond and Gigi’s in Montauk use OpenTable, and LDV at The Maidstone sends you to SevenRooms. Here is what you can book now, village by village, then how each summer room opens, so the same page works when you are planning July in March. Everything is as of November 2026, from each restaurant’s own site unless noted.
Sag Harbor: the village that never really closes
- The American Hotel (Resy, Main Street). The 1846 whaling-era hotel dining room, with a wine list that has held Wine Spectator’s Grand Award since 1981. Its site says you can reserve “breakfast, lunch or dinner every day of the week, every day of the year,” from 8am to 10pm, and it takes phone bookings too. Collared shirts are required, in capital letters. Book The American Hotel with SeatSwiper
- Sag Harbor Tavern (OpenTable, Bay Street). Billy Durney’s follow-up to Red Hook Tavern, built around the dry-aged burger. It books on OpenTable and Dorsia, takes parties of two to eight, and holds the door for walk-ins of up to six. Dinner runs nightly from 5pm, lunch Wednesday to Sunday. OpenTable’s schedule shows a 14-day window opening at midnight as of November 2026, so Christmas Eve goes on sale the night of December 10 and New Year’s Eve on December 17. Book Sag Harbor Tavern with SeatSwiper
- Lulu Kitchen & Bar (Resy, Main Street). A wood-fired bistro that says it is open every day, with dinner from 5:30pm, lunch Monday to Saturday and a Sunday brunch from 11:30am. It is the safe call for a Monday. Book Lulu Kitchen & Bar with SeatSwiper
- Zagara at Faraway (Resy, harborfront). The Faraway hotel’s Amalfi-leaning room, oysters and coastal plates over the harbor. Its posted hours are Tuesday to Saturday 5 to 10pm and Sunday 5 to 9pm, closed Mondays, and there is a private dining room for a group. Book Faraway Sag Harbor & Zagara with SeatSwiper
SeatSwiper watches the Hamptons table you want and books it in your name the moment one opens. First booking free.
Start a Hamptons watchEast Hampton, Bridgehampton and Amagansett
- Nick & Toni’s (Resy, East Hampton). The 1988 Tuscan farmhouse with the wood-burning oven. It opens Wednesday to Monday from 5:30pm and closes Tuesdays. It publishes no booking window and asks you not to request tables by email; book through Resy. Sunday to Thursday it runs a $34 two-course pizza and pasta prix fixe, which makes a weeknight the easier ask. Groups of up to 30 can take one of its two rooms. Book Nick & Toni’s with SeatSwiper
- LDV at The Maidstone (SevenRooms, East Hampton). LDV Hospitality’s Italian room in the Main Street hotel. The site says the restaurant is open year-round, and its current dinner hours are Thursday to Saturday, 5:30 to 9pm. Its own Book a Table link goes to SevenRooms, so start there rather than at an older Resy listing.
- Fresno (Resy, East Hampton). The skylit neighborhood room on Fresno Place, a few blocks off Main Street. Open six nights from 5pm, closed Wednesdays, and it will take a booking by phone at 631-324-8700 as well as on Resy. Book Fresno with SeatSwiper
- Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House (Resy, Bridgehampton). The 1842 mansion’s restaurant, cooking from East End farms and boats. The hotel says it is open year-round for breakfast, lunch and dinner; the poolside Champagne Studio that absorbs extra diners is a summer-weekend room only. Book Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House with SeatSwiper
- Almond (OpenTable, Bridgehampton). Jason Weiner’s bistro on Ocean Road, dinner Tuesday to Saturday, closed Sunday and Monday. OpenTable’s schedule runs 30 days ahead from midnight as of November 2026, so a Thursday New Year’s Eve opens on December 1. Book Almond with SeatSwiper
- Il Buco al Mare (Resy, Amagansett). The Il Buco team’s seafood house on Main Street. The group’s page lists it open seven days, noon to 9pm Sunday to Thursday and to 10pm on Friday and Saturday, so lunch is a real option here. Book Il Buco Al Mare with SeatSwiper
- Stone Creek Inn (Resy, East Quogue). Christian Mir’s French house, heading into its 30th season. It takes reservations up to four weeks ahead, holds every one with a card and charges $25 a person if you cancel inside 24 hours. Fall hours are Thursday to Sunday from 5pm, with a $45 two-course prix fixe on Sundays and Thursdays. Book Stone Creek Inn with SeatSwiper
Montauk after Labor Day
In Montauk the winter list is the shortest of all. The Montauk Yacht Club says it is closed for the 2026 season and back in 2027, which takes Alba Spiaggia off the board until then. What stays lit is Gurney’s.
- Gigi’s (OpenTable, Gurney’s Montauk). The resort’s coastal American room. This winter it runs a three-course prix fixe Sunday to Thursday (not on holidays), a 4 to 6pm Sunset Hour at the bar, and heated igloos from October 16 to April 4. OpenTable’s schedule shows about 121 days of book as of November 2026, which is why its calendar already reaches into March. Gurney’s five-course New Year’s Eve dinner is at Scarpetta Beach, which books separately; Gigi’s takes New Year’s Day brunch. Book Gigi’s Montauk with SeatSwiper
The summer rooms, and how each one opens
- The Surf Lodge (Resy, Montauk). Its own restaurant page says parties of nine or fewer book on Resy “beginning 14 days in advance.” It names no release hour, so check early on the morning 14 days out. Ten to 24 people email dining@thesurflodge.com, and deck and beach tables have their own address, beachdeck@thesurflodge.com. Fourteen days keeps the weekday, so a Saturday opens on a Saturday. No 2027 opening date is posted yet. Book The Surf Lodge with SeatSwiper
- Si Si (EHP Resort & Marina). The boat-up Mediterranean room says it is closed for à la carte dining for the 2026 season, though it is still taking groups and private events through the end of the year at sisi.reservations@ehphospitality.com. While it is closed, its pages carry no booking link or window, so the 2027 rule is the thing to confirm when the season is announced.
- Moby’s (Resy, East Hampton). The seasonal Italian house on Pantigo Road says it opens each year in season, late May through November. Groups larger than eight use its separate large-party form instead of Resy. Book Moby’s with SeatSwiper
- Wayan & Ma.Dé (EHP Resort & Marina) and Alba Spiaggia (Montauk Yacht Club) both post “closed for the 2026 season.” Neither has announced a reopening date on its own site.
The dates to put in a calendar
Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve both fall on a Thursday this year. On the published windows, Almond opens Christmas Eve on November 24 and New Year’s Eve on December 1. Stone Creek’s four weeks land on November 26 and December 3, and Sag Harbor Tavern’s 14 days on December 10 and December 17. The American Hotel books every day of the year, so it is the fallback when those are gone.
For next summer, Memorial Day is Monday, May 31, 2027, which makes Saturday, May 29 the night everyone wants. Gigi’s 121-day book reaches it on January 28, Stone Creek on May 1, Sag Harbor Tavern and the Surf Lodge on May 15. For Saturday, July 3, Gigi’s opens around March 4 and the Surf Lodge on June 19. The general rules are in what time Resy releases reservations and when OpenTable releases reservations.
When a full Hamptons night comes back
Stone Creek’s $25-a-head fee inside 24 hours gives anyone whose plans changed a reason to let go a day or two before, so look again 48 hours out rather than that afternoon. The reasoning is in how restaurant cancellation policies work. Sag Harbor Tavern’s door takes up to six, and Fresno and The American Hotel will talk to you on the phone. LDV’s SevenRooms book has its own habits, covered in how SevenRooms works. Across the bay, the North Fork restaurant reservations guide covers Shelter Island and Greenport, and the city’s own list is the hardest restaurants to book in NYC.
Resy, OpenTable and SevenRooms in one watch
Out east the hard part is that the tables live on three systems and open at different hours: midnight on OpenTable for Sag Harbor Tavern, a four-week Resy book at Stone Creek, a 14-day one at the Surf Lodge. I built SeatSwiper to watch Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable and book the table the moment one opens, whether that is a new date entering the window or a cancellation a day before. It books on your own account, in your name, and nothing is resold or transferred. It can’t get your account banned, because it books on your own account and checks every few minutes, never nonstop. The first booking is free. After that it is a flat $5, charged only when it actually books the table, with no subscription. A cancellation watch on a date that is already full costs $1 to start, charged when the watch begins even if no table ever opens; that $1 is not covered by the free first booking and is not refunded, and the same $5 applies if the watch wins you the table. The limits: it works only on those three platforms, it needs your login to book as you, and on a July Saturday it can lose the race.
FAQ
Which Hamptons restaurants are open in the winter?
As of November 2026, The American Hotel in Sag Harbor takes reservations every day of the year and Lulu Kitchen & Bar says it is open every day. Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House and LDV at The Maidstone are open year-round, Nick & Toni’s runs Wednesday to Monday, and Gigi’s at Gurney’s Montauk has a Sunday to Thursday winter prix fixe. Si Si, Wayan and Alba Spiaggia are closed for the 2026 season.
When do Surf Lodge reservations open?
Fourteen days ahead on Resy. The Surf Lodge’s own restaurant page says parties of nine or fewer book on Resy beginning 14 days in advance; it names no release hour. Groups of 10 to 24 email dining@thesurflodge.com, and deck and beach tables go through beachdeck@thesurflodge.com. It is a summer room with no 2027 opening date posted yet; for Saturday, May 29, the table would appear on May 15.
Is Si Si in East Hampton open now?
Not for regular dinner. Si Si, the Mediterranean restaurant at EHP Resort & Marina on Three Mile Harbor, says it is closed for à la carte dining for the 2026 season, though it is still taking groups, private events and weddings through the end of the year at sisi.reservations@ehphospitality.com. While closed, its own pages show no booking link or window, so confirm how 2027 books when the season is announced.
How far ahead can you book Sag Harbor Tavern?
OpenTable’s schedule shows 14 days, with new dates opening at midnight, as of November 2026. The tavern also lists Dorsia, takes parties of two to eight, and welcomes walk-ins of up to six first come, first served. On that window, Christmas Eve opens the night of December 10 and New Year’s Eve on December 17.